Performance Anxiety: How One Failed Erection Becomes a Pattern

Most men have an erection fail at some point. Tiredness, alcohol, stress, a new partner or an argument earlier in the day can all be enough. For most, the next occasion goes normally and the episode is forgotten.

For some men, the next occasion starts with a question: will it happen again? That anticipation changes what happens in the body, and it can turn one failure into a pattern.

The physiology of alarm

An erection depends on the parasympathetic nervous system, the part that governs rest and digestion. Its signals relax the smooth muscle of the penile arteries and erectile tissue, and blood flows in.

Anxiety activates the opposing sympathetic system. Its main messenger, noradrenaline, contracts the same smooth muscle. It narrows the arteries and keeps the erectile tissue firm and closed. The penis stays flaccid, or an erection that has begun subsides. The two systems work against each other, and in a state of alarm the sympathetic side usually wins.

This is why a man can have normal erections on waking and during masturbation and still lose them with a partner. The machinery works. The conditions in which it is being asked to work have changed.

Where attention goes

In the 1980s, the psychologist David Barlow studied sexual arousal in the laboratory in men with and without erectile problems. His model, supported by later experiments, proposed that the two groups respond differently to pressure to perform.

Men without erectile problems tend to stay focused on erotic sensations, and pressure can even increase their arousal. Men with erectile problems tend to shift their attention to monitoring the erection and to the consequences of failure. That monitoring takes attention away from arousal, the erection weakens, and the weakening confirms the fear.

Sex therapists call the monitoring “spectatoring”: watching the performance from the outside instead of taking part in it. It becomes a habit, and each failure strengthens it.

How the pattern builds

1. An erection fails for an ordinary reason.
2. Before the next occasion, the man anticipates failure.
3. During sex, he monitors his erection instead of attending to sensation.
4. Anxiety and distraction weaken the erection.
5. The failure confirms the fear and raises the stakes for next time.

Avoidance often follows. Men start to avoid sex, rush it while the erection lasts, or withdraw from affection that might lead to sex. Partners may read that withdrawal as rejection, which adds strain to the relationship.

Anxiety and physical causes often combine

Performance anxiety is sometimes the whole explanation. More often it is part of one. A man with a mild physical problem, such as early vascular change or venous leak, has a failure, and anxiety then makes every later attempt harder. Treating only the anxiety or only the physical cause can leave the other in place.

Some signs point toward a mainly psychological cause:

• Normal erections on waking and during masturbation
• A sudden start linked to a specific event
• Erections that vary a lot with the situation or partner

Loss of morning erections, a gradual decline over months or years, or erections that fade in every situation point toward a physical contribution. Our article on erectile dysfunction in men under 40 explains why anxiety is often assumed without checking.

What breaks the pattern

Removing the demand

Sensate focus is a structured program used in sex therapy. A couple agrees to a period of touching without intercourse, often starting with non-genital touch and progressing in stages. With intercourse off the table, there is nothing to fail at. Attention returns to sensation, and erections often return with it. The approach is usually guided by a therapist.

Psychological treatment

Cognitive behavioral therapy and sex therapy address the anticipatory thoughts and the monitoring habit directly. The 2018 AUA guideline recommends that clinicians consider referral to a mental health professional for men with erectile dysfunction, partly to reduce performance anxiety.

Temporary medication

Some men use a PDE5 inhibitor for a period to rebuild confidence. A few reliable erections can interrupt the cycle, after which some men no longer need the tablet. This works best alongside the other approaches.

Talking to your partner

Anxiety is heavier when it is hidden. Telling a partner what is happening, and that it is not about attraction, removes one source of pressure. Many partners are relieved to hear an explanation for changes they had noticed.

If anxiety is part of a wider picture

General anxiety and depression both affect sexual function, and some of the medications used to treat them do too. If low mood, persistent worry or sleep problems are present, raise them with a doctor. Do not stop or change a prescribed antidepressant without speaking to the prescriber. Our article on antidepressants and sexual side effects covers the options.

Related reading

• Erectile Dysfunction in Men Under 40: Causes, Warning Signs, and What to Ask For
• Antidepressants and Sexual Side Effects
• Pornography and Erectile Function: What the Evidence Shows
• Sildenafil and Tadalafil: Why the First Attempts Often Fail

References

• Barlow DH. Causes of sexual dysfunction: the role of anxiety and cognitive interference. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 1986;54(2):140-148. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3700800/
• Beck JG, Barlow DH. The effects of anxiety and attentional focus on sexual responding. II: Cognitive and affective patterns in erectile dysfunction. Behaviour Research and Therapy. 1986;24:19-26.
• Burnett AL, Nehra A, Breau RH, et al. Erectile Dysfunction: AUA Guideline. Journal of Urology. 2018;200(3):633-641. Statement 6. AUA Guidelines page

If you have questions about anything in this article, write to us at hello@xialla.com. We read and answer every message.